Term paper on The Prevalent Issues Of Surrogate Parenting

The Prevalent Issues Of Surrogate Parenting Essays

While the free essays can give you inspiration for writing, they cannot be used 'as is' because they will not meet your assignment's requirements. If you are in a time crunch, then you need a custom written term paper on your subject (the prevalent issues of surrogate parenting)
Here you can hire an independent writer/researcher to custom write you an authentic essay to your specifications that will pass any plagiarism test (e.g. Turnitin). Waste no more time!

The Prevalent Issues of Surrogate Parenting

Surrogate parenting refers to an arrangement between a married couple

who is unable to have a child because of the wife's infertility and a fertile

woman who agrees to conceive the husband's child through artificial insemination,

carry it to term, then surrender all parental rights in the child. Often, the

surrogate mother receives compensation for her services. The final step in the

process is typically the father's acknowledgment of paternity and adoption, with

his wife, of the child. Through surrogate motherhood, a couple desiring a child

need not wait an indefinite number of years for an adoptable baby, as generally

happens at the present time. The married couple obtains a child who is the

husband's biological offspring- a child for whose existence both husband and

wife can feel responsible.

Surrogate parenting is highly controversial by its very nature.

Nevertheless, surrogate parenting is attracting wide spread attention as a

viable alternative for infertile couples intent on having a child. Contract

surrogacy is officially little more than ten years old, although surrogate

mothering is a practice that has been known since biblical times. In 1986 alone

500 babies had been born to mothers who gave them up to sperm donor fathers for

a fee, and the practice is growing rapidly.

For this reason there are many questions and doubts that arise from this

subject. Often there are many legal difficulties that come about with surrogate

parenting. In some states the contracts that insure the infertile couple the

baby of the surrogate mother mean nothing. This, in turn, can cause huge

problems if the surrogate mother were to change her mind about giving up her

child. Who has the rights to the child in this awful situation? Surrogate

parenting is a wonderful alternative for infertile couples as long as all

party's involved are educated on the subject and are fully aware of the pros

and cons of this risky business transaction.

Unfortunately laws on surrogate parenting aren't very helpful.

Increasing numbers of surrogate custody cases are finding their way into the

courtrooms. The most dramatic problem arises when the surrogate mother decides

she wants to keep the baby.Whether she decides early or late in the pregnancy,

at birth, or after the child is born, the ultimate issue is whether she or the

infertile couple have parental rights.

How is the law to respond to this kind of problem? Normally people

would agree that a contract is a contract and therefore the infertile couple

should be the ones to receive the baby. Unfortunately for some of us more

sympathetic people this decision is not that simple. By changing her mind the

surrogate mother is showing maternal feelings that are surely not reprehensible.

Although she has promised to give up the baby her change of heart seems more

understandable than dishonorable. After all how can a woman truly be expected

to know how it will feel to give birth to a child and then have to give it up?

These are very good questions that tend to leave one undecided as to which

party's demand is justifiable and should be upheld.

Instead of deciding surrogacy issues on the basis of the law and policy

of the states, judges could look for guidance from the U.S. Constitution.

Constitutional arguments can be made on both sides of the classic surrogacy

dispute involving the mother who changes her mind about giving up her child.

Resolution of the constitutional issues will depend ultimately upon assessing

and weighing the various factors at stake. Like decisions based on contract and

criminal law, constitutional decisions will take account of the party's

interests, the child's interests, society's interests, and the effectiveness of

legalization and regulation as opposed to prohibition.

Many Americans remained unaware of these dramas, but virtually everyone

in the United States became aquainted during 1987 with the plight of Mary Beth

Whitehead and “Baby M”. Mrs. Whitehead was a twenty-nine year old house wife.

She already had two children, and decided she would be the surrogate mother for

a couple by the name of Mr. and Mrs. William and Elizabeth Stern. The Sterns

were 40 and 41 years old. They had been married for 12 years and were childless.

Mrs. Stern had a mild case of multiple sclerosis and was unable to bare any

children.

Although Whitehead promised in the contract that she would form no bond

with the baby, she knew in the delivery room she could not give up her child.

Whitehead ended up kidnapping the new born. The case proceeded to a much-

publicized trial entailing six weeks of testimony and half a million dollars in

legal bills.

Unfortunately many surrogate agreements end with a tragic conclusion

similar to this one. These awful outcomes could be completely avoided if the

law would include in its many clauses, unconditional protection against any

infringement upon the contract between the surrogate mother and the infertile

parents.

In order for surrogacy to work with its initial intent, there can be no

exceptions to this law. Although there will be cases in which the enforcement

of these laws may be seemingly harsh and apathetic, it is the only way that this

wonderful alternative for infertile parents can rightfully continue, without

potentially ruining the lives of all parties involved, most importantly the

child's.

Although the rights of the infertile couple...

You should cite this paper as follows:

MLA Style
. EssayMania.com. Retrieved on 12 Feb, 2012 from
    <http://essaymania.com/43963/the-prevalent-issues-of-surrogate-parenting>

More College Papers

UFOs: We Are Not Alone
UFOs: We Are Not Alone OUTLINE I. THINGS IN THE SKY A. THE FIRST DOCUMENTED SIGHTING B. THE FEVER SPREADS 1. PILOT ENCOUNTERS 2. THE LIGHTS IN THE SKY II. DENTS IN THE EARTH III. UNEXPLAINED PHENOMENON

Women In The House of Commons
Women In The House of Commons More and more women are being elected to the House of Commons today. However, this does not mean that there is an increase in the mobilization of women's issues. There is a need for a "critical mass" to be achieved before the voices of women shall be heard in

My Great-Grandmother was not a Person
My Great-Grandmother was not a Person My Great-Grandmother was not a person. Neither was yours. Up until about 67 years ago no females were. We were supposed to be pregnant and barefoot in the kitchen. At least that's the perception that the laws enforced. (For ex: The Election Act of the